MDR vs EDR vs Antivirus: What Each One Does and Who Watches the Alerts
Plain definitions of antivirus, next-generation antivirus, EDR, XDR, and MDR, who responds to alerts in each, typical published prices, and what cyber insurers ask.
Antivirus, EDR, XDR, and MDR defined
Antivirus and EDR are software on your devices, XDR is software that pulls in more sources, and MDR is a service where outside analysts watch and respond for you. The definitions below come from NIST and Microsoft:
| Term | What it is | What it watches | Who acts on alerts |
|---|---|---|---|
| Antivirus | NIST: a program that monitors a computer or network to identify all major types of malware and prevent or contain malware incidents | Files and programs on the device | The software blocks known threats on its own |
| Next-generation antivirus (NGAV) | Antivirus that uses machine learning, behavior analysis, and cloud-delivered protection to block new threats, not only known ones | Files and process behavior on the device | The software blocks threats on its own |
| Endpoint detection and response (EDR) | Software that continuously collects activity from devices, detects attacks in near real time, and creates alerts for an analyst to investigate | Processes, network activity, sign-ins, registry and file changes on each device | Your IT team or a provider must review alerts and take action |
| Extended detection and response (XDR) | A platform that brings together data from endpoints, networks, clouds, email, and identities | Devices plus email, identity, network, and cloud | Your IT team or a provider. XDR is software, not a staffed service |
| Managed detection and response (MDR) | A service that pairs security tools with human analysts who monitor, hunt, and respond to threats | Whatever tools the provider runs or connects to | The provider's analysts |
The real difference is who watches the alerts
EDR finds suspicious activity, but someone still has to look at each alert and decide what to do. Microsoft describes EDR alerts as created for an analyst to investigate. If no one is watching at 2 a.m., the alert waits until morning. That gap is what MDR fills.
EDR you run yourself
With a tool such as Microsoft Defender for Business, your team or IT partner reviews alerts and takes actions such as isolating a device, stopping and quarantining a file, or running a scan. Microsoft's overview does not describe a Microsoft-run monitoring service for Defender for Business.
Managed EDR
Some products include a staffed security operations center (SOC). Huntress, for example, states that its Managed EDR pricing includes the security expertise of its 24/7 SOC. Deployment and day-to-day portal management are not included in that price.
Full MDR
An MDR service takes on monitoring, investigation, and response across the tools it covers. CrowdStrike, for example, describes Falcon Complete as 24/7 expert-led managed detection and response, priced through sales.
What each typically costs
Published prices for self-managed and managed EDR run from a few dollars to about ten dollars per user or device per month. Full MDR services are usually priced through sales, so the MDR row below is a planning range, not a published price. Vendors price per user, per device, or per endpoint, so convert to the same unit before you compare. List prices as published in November 2026, plus one planning range:
| Product or service | Type | Published price or planning range | Who watches alerts | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Microsoft Defender for Business (standalone) | NGAV and EDR | $3.00 per user per month, billed yearly | Your team or IT partner | Covers up to 5 devices per user, for up to 300 users. Included in Microsoft 365 Business Premium |
| CrowdStrike Falcon Go | NGAV, device control, and other features, with EDR listed | $59.99 per device per year | Your team or IT partner | Limited to 100 devices per purchase. Also sold at $7.99 per device per month |
| Huntress Managed EDR | Managed EDR | $8.99 per endpoint per month (MSRP) | Huntress 24/7 SOC, included | Per-unit rate drops with volume. 50-seat minimum when bought direct or through a reseller; none through an MSP |
| MDR service | Managed detection and response | About $20 to $50 per user per month | The provider's analysts, 24/7 | Days Dynamics planning range, not a quote. Cost depends on scope, tools covered, and response terms |
What cyber insurers ask about EDR
Cyber insurance applications commonly ask whether you run EDR on all endpoints and whether someone monitors security alerts around the clock. Questions like these, paraphrased from the State of Indiana's Cybersecurity Hub and a Beazley ransomware supplemental application (May 2022 edition), include:
- Do you use an advanced endpoint detection and response (EDR) tool on all endpoints?
- Which EDR and managed detection and response (MDR) vendors do you use?
- Do you have a security operations center, and is it staffed during working hours only or 24/7? Is it internal or a third party?
- Does your SOC have the authority and ability to remediate security events, for example by isolating endpoints remotely?
- Do you use a SIEM monitored 24x7 by a SOC?
- Do you require multifactor authentication for remote access, web-based email, cloud services, and administrator accounts?
- Do you keep offline or immutable backups, and do you test them for restorability?
See the endpoint protection planning page.
How the layers fit together
Most organizations use these as layers: next-generation antivirus blocks known and likely threats, EDR records what happens on each device and flags attacks, and MDR adds people to act on those flags. Defender for Business, for example, includes both next-generation protection and EDR in one product. The decision that matters most is who will watch and respond to alerts, and how fast, including nights and weekends.
Which should you choose?
Match the tool to who will respond when an alert fires. Use this list as a starting point:
- Antivirus alone is rarely enough for an organization that holds sensitive data or carries cyber insurance
- Choose self-managed EDR if you have IT staff who can review alerts every day and respond quickly
- Choose managed EDR if you want EDR plus a staffed SOC watching it, without a full MDR contract
- Choose MDR if no one on your team can watch alerts 24/7, or your insurer or customers expect round-the-clock monitoring
- Whatever you choose, confirm it covers every endpoint, since insurers ask about all endpoints
Plan your endpoint security with Days Dynamics
Tell us how many users and devices you have, what you run today, and what your cyber insurer is asking. We will help you compare self-managed EDR, managed EDR, and MDR for your environment. A planning call is planning support, not a quote, an audit, or a commitment on pricing, coverage, or response times.
Sources
Primary sources checked when this guide was written. Dates and product status can change, so confirm on the source before you rely on them.
- NIST CSRC Glossary: Antivirus software (opens in a new tab)
- Microsoft Learn: Next-generation protection in Microsoft Defender Antivirus (opens in a new tab)
- Microsoft Learn: Overview of endpoint detection and response (opens in a new tab)
- Microsoft Security: What is XDR? (opens in a new tab)
- Microsoft Security: What is managed detection and response (MDR)? (opens in a new tab)
- Microsoft Learn: Microsoft Defender for Business overview (opens in a new tab)
- Microsoft: Microsoft Defender for Business pricing (opens in a new tab)
- CrowdStrike: Falcon pricing (opens in a new tab)
- Huntress: Pricing (opens in a new tab)
- Indiana Cybersecurity Hub: Underwriting security controls questions (opens in a new tab)
- Beazley: Ransomware supplemental application (opens in a new tab)
Related services
Related resources
Turn the checklist into a plan
The 2-minute IT quiz turns this checklist into ranked priorities for your situation, before any contact details.
