Skip to main content
Guide, 8 minute read

HIPAA Risk Analysis for Small Practices: What OCR Enforcement Shows

What the HIPAA Security Rule's risk analysis requirement says, what HHS press releases on OCR settlements show was missing, where the proposed Security Rule update stands, and how a small medical or dental practice prepares.

Planning guidesPractice owners, office managers, and IT leads at small medical and dental practicesBy , Founder and CEO, Days Dynamics. Published November 13, 2026.

What a HIPAA risk analysis is, and why OCR keeps citing it

Under 45 CFR 164.308(a)(1)(ii)(A), a covered practice must conduct an accurate and thorough assessment of the potential risks and vulnerabilities to the confidentiality, integrity, and availability of its electronic protected health information (ePHI). HHS lists it as required. OCR settlements announced by HHS, including with small practices, repeatedly name a missing or incomplete risk analysis. This guide is IT planning help, not legal advice.

What 45 CFR 164.308(a)(1)(ii)(A) requires

The risk analysis sits inside the Security Rule's security management process, which also requires managing the risks it finds. HHS states there is no single method, the analysis must be documented but in no specific format, and the process should be ongoing. The Security Rule does not specify how often to repeat it.

RequirementWhat the rule or HHS saysWhere it comes from
Risk analysis (Required)Conduct an accurate and thorough assessment of the potential risks and vulnerabilities to the confidentiality, integrity, and availability of electronic protected health information held by the [organization]45 CFR 164.308(a)(1)(ii)(A), as quoted in HHS risk analysis guidance
Risk managementManage risks by implementing security measures that reduce risks and vulnerabilities to a reasonable and appropriate levelHHS summary of the Security Rule
Ongoing reviewRegularly reevaluate potential risks to ePHI; the Security Rule does not specify how frequently to perform risk analysisHHS summary and risk analysis guidance
DocumentationDocumented, in no required format, and kept until six years after the later of its creation or the date it was last in effectHHS risk analysis guidance and Security Rule summary
ScopeePHI in every electronic medium the practice uses, including portable electronic mediaHHS risk analysis guidance

What OCR settlements show was missing

Each row below comes from an HHS press release, using the wording OCR used. HHS numbers many of these releases as actions in OCR's Risk Analysis Initiative; the June 18, 2026 release was the 14th. Amounts are what each entity paid to OCR, and each settlement also came with a corrective action plan that OCR monitors.

HHS releaseEntity, as HHS describes itPaid to OCRWhat OCR said was missing
April 25, 2025Comprehensive Neurology, PC, a small New York neurology practice (8th Risk Analysis Initiative action)$25,000An accurate and thorough risk analysis, after ransomware encrypted its network
May 15, 2025Vision Upright MRI, a small California health care provider$5,000OCR found it had never conducted a risk analysis, and breach notices were not timely
February 19, 2026Top of the World Ranch Treatment Center, a substance use disorder treatment provider in Illinois (11th)$103,000An accurate and thorough risk analysis
March 5, 2026MMG Fusion, LLC, a Maryland software company acting as a business associate (12th)$10,000An accurate and thorough risk analysis, and notice of the breach to its covered entity customers
April 23, 2026Four ransomware settlements: a women's health provider network, an imaging provider, a benefits administrator, and a health plan$1,165,000 combinedAn accurate and thorough risk analysis, in all four
June 18, 2026The group health plan of Spencer Gifts LLC, a national retail company (14th)$450,000An accurate and thorough risk analysis, and reasonable and appropriate policies and procedures
September 17, 2026Ambry Genetics Corporation, headquartered in Aliso Viejo, California$700,000An accurate and thorough risk analysis, procedures for terminating access, and unique user identification
October 29, 2026Lehigh Valley Health Network, a health system in Pennsylvania$800,000An accurate and thorough risk analysis of all of its ePHI, and regular review of system activity records such as audit logs

What the settlements have in common

The risk analysis is named every time

In every release in the table, OCR listed a missing, incomplete, or never-performed risk analysis among the problems its investigation found.

A breach usually started the investigation

Most of these cases followed a reported breach, and several followed ransomware. The risk analysis gap came to light during the investigation that followed.

Small practices are in the cases too

HHS describes Comprehensive Neurology and Vision Upright MRI as small providers. In the May 15, 2025 release, OCR's Acting Director said that cybersecurity threats affect large and small covered health care providers.

The fix is a plan, not only a payment

Comprehensive Neurology's corrective action plan requires a risk analysis, a risk management plan, revised HIPAA policies as needed, and workforce training, monitored by OCR for two years.

What OCR recommends, and the IT evidence behind each step

HHS's April 23, 2026 release lists these recommended steps for covered entities and business associates, and the June 18, 2026 release repeats them. Each one maps to records an IT team can produce.

OCR's recommendationIT evidence that supports it
Identify where ePHI is located and how it enters, moves through, and leaves your systemsAn asset inventory of computers, servers, imaging and lab devices, and cloud applications, plus a simple data-flow map
Conduct and update the risk analysis regularly, and keep a risk management planA dated risk register: each risk, its level, the fix, an owner, and a target date
Implement audit controls and regularly review system activitySign-in and audit logging turned on in Microsoft 365, the practice management system, and servers, with a review schedule
Use authentication so only authorized users access ePHIA unique login for every person, multi-factor authentication, and access removed promptly when staff leave
Encrypt ePHI in transit and at rest where appropriateEncryption on laptops and workstations, encrypted backups, and encrypted email for outside recipients
Apply lessons from security incidents to the security management processAn incident log, with notes on what changed after each event
Provide regular, role-specific HIPAA trainingTraining records by role, including phishing awareness

Where the proposed Security Rule update stands

HHS issued a proposed rule to strengthen the Security Rule on December 27, 2024, published in the Federal Register on January 6, 2025. HHS states that the current Security Rule remains in effect during the rulemaking. As checked November 13, 2026, the Federal Register lists only the proposed rule, and the rule's federal regulatory agenda entry on Reginfo.gov places it under Long-Term Actions with final action listed for July 2027. The proposed requirements are not law.

Asset inventory and network map

Proposed: a written technology asset inventory and network map, reviewed on an ongoing basis and at least once every 12 months.

A more detailed written risk analysis

Proposed: a review of the asset inventory and network map, identification of all reasonably anticipated threats and potential vulnerabilities, and a risk level for each.

Scanning and testing

Proposed: vulnerability scanning at least every six months and penetration testing at least once every 12 months, plus a compliance audit at least once every 12 months.

Required and addressable

Proposed: removing the distinction between required and addressable implementation specifications.

How to use the proposal now

Treat the list as a planning checklist, not a deadline. An accurate asset inventory and network map make the current risk analysis easier to do well.

How a small practice prepares its risk analysis

HHS's risk analysis guidance organizes the work into the steps below. HealthIT.gov's Security Risk Assessment (SRA) Tool, developed by ONC with OCR for medium and small providers, walks through a similar process. HealthIT.gov states that using it is neither required by nor guarantees compliance with federal, state or local laws.

  • Set the scope. Include every place ePHI lives: workstations, servers, laptops, phones, imaging and lab devices, backups, removable media, and cloud services such as Microsoft 365 and the practice management system.
  • Collect the data. Gather the asset inventory, network map, vendor list, and existing policies.
  • Identify and document threats and vulnerabilities. Record risks such as ransomware, phishing, a lost laptop, an unsupported operating system, or a shared login.
  • Assess current security measures. Note what is in place today: MFA, endpoint protection, backups and restore tests, encryption, and access reviews.
  • Determine likelihood and impact. Rate how likely each threat is and how much harm it would do to patient care and patient data.
  • Determine the level of risk. Combine likelihood and impact so the highest risks are fixed first.
  • Finalize the documentation. Write it down, date it, and keep it with the risk management plan.
  • Review and update it. Revisit it when the practice adds a system, moves, changes vendors, or has a security incident, and at a regular interval the practice sets.

See the Microsoft 365 Security Baseline Review and the Free cyber insurance renewal readiness check.

Where Days Dynamics fits, and where it does not

Days Dynamics provides IT and security work that produces the evidence a risk analysis relies on. Days Dynamics does not provide legal or compliance advice, does not act as a practice's security official, and does not certify HIPAA compliance. Compliance decisions belong with the practice and its own legal or compliance advisors.

Inventory and network map

Listing devices, software versions, and cloud services, and drawing how they connect.

Microsoft 365 settings

The Microsoft 365 Security Baseline Review checks MFA coverage, admin roles, sign-in protections, mail forwarding, sharing, and backup in the tenant with read-only access.

Backups and endpoints

Planning tested backups and endpoint protection across the devices staff use.

Insurance questions

If a cyber insurance renewal is also due, the free readiness check marks each security question on the application yes, partly, or no, with the fix path for each gap.

See the IT for healthcare and dental practices and the Healthcare and dental IT in Las Vegas.

Frequently asked questions

Are the proposed HIPAA Security Rule changes law?

No. As checked November 13, 2026, the Federal Register lists only the proposed rule, and HHS states that the current Security Rule remains in effect. Its federal regulatory agenda entry on Reginfo.gov lists final action for July 2027, which is a projected date, not a final rule.

How often does a practice have to update its risk analysis?

The Security Rule does not specify how frequently. HHS states that the risk analysis process should be ongoing and that regulated entities should regularly reevaluate potential risks to ePHI.

Is the HHS SRA Tool enough on its own?

HealthIT.gov states that using the tool is neither required by nor guarantees compliance. It is a structured way to document the analysis, and the practice still has to act on what it finds.

What did OCR's small-practice settlements cost?

Comprehensive Neurology, described by HHS as a small New York neurology practice, paid $25,000. Vision Upright MRI, a small California provider, paid $5,000. Both agreed to corrective action plans monitored by OCR for two years.

Is this legal or compliance advice?

No. It summarizes HHS publications to help plan IT work. Days Dynamics provides IT and security work, not legal or compliance advice, so confirm your obligations with your own advisors.

Get the IT side of your risk analysis in order

Send us a short list of the systems your practice runs and what you already document. We will help build the asset inventory, check Microsoft 365 settings, and plan fixes for the risks your analysis finds. Days Dynamics provides IT and security work, not legal or compliance advice. A planning call is planning support, not a quote, an audit, a guarantee, or a commitment on pricing, availability, or delivery dates.

Sources

Primary sources checked when this guide was written. Dates and product status can change, so confirm on the source before you rely on them.

Planning this project now?

Turn the checklist into a plan

The 2-minute IT quiz turns this checklist into ranked priorities for your situation, before any contact details.